CMS Exclusion Authority: What Podiatry Practices Need to Know Now

Podiatry practice reviewing Medicare compliance documentation after the CMS exclusion authority delegation
Created by: The Billing Service Quotes Editorial Team.
Technical Review: Tim Daniels, Director of Strategic Accounts, Billing Service Quotes

What Does CMS Exclusion Authority Mean for Podiatry Practices?

As of October 2026, CMS exclusion authority refers to the power HHS delegated to CMS on October 14 to bar providers from Medicare, Medicaid, and other federal health programs, a tool previously held only by the OIG. For podiatry practices, already a frequent OIG audit target, it means a second enforcer reviewing routine foot care and modifier 25 claims.

What changed:
CMS can now impose permissive exclusions under section 1128(b) of the Social Security Act, and a senior CMS official says payment suspensions should quadruple within six months.

Why podiatry is exposed:
OIG audits found nearly half of sampled podiatry routine foot care claims noncompliant and an estimated $39.6 million in improper modifier 25 E/M payments.

What protects you:
Clean documentation, correct Q modifiers, and a billing team that audits claims before submission, not after a records request arrives.

What CMS Announced in October 2026

On October 14, 2026, HHS published a Statement of Delegation of Authority in the Federal Register (Document 2026-21001, 91 FR 65219), delegating the Secretary’s permissive exclusion authority under section 1128(b) of the Social Security Act to the CMS Administrator, effective immediately. The notice says CMS requested the authority because, as the agency that runs Medicare and Medicaid, it is positioned to investigate and build the evidence behind exclusion decisions.

The delegation has limits. It covers permissive exclusions only, not mandatory exclusions under section 1128(a) or civil monetary penalties under section 1128A. It excludes the authority to conduct hearings and to issue regulations, and it does not reduce the OIG’s existing exclusion authority. Legal analysts have also noted that the delegation creates no new grounds for exclusion, so CMS still needs a statutory basis and supporting evidence for any action.

The next day, Deputy CMS Administrator Kimberly Brandt told the ADAPT conference in Santa Fe that she hopes provider payment suspensions will quadruple over the next six months, as reported by Nextgov/FCW on October 15. Her presentation credited the agency’s Medicaid War Room, launched in April, with blocking $342 million in improper payments and issuing 124 notices of intent to exclude through September. CMS is also using an algorithm that places newly enrolled providers flagged as high risk under six months of added monitoring.

None of this changes a podiatry coding rule. What changes is the enforcement environment around the rules you already follow, and how quickly a problem can turn into a cash flow event.

Which Podiatry Practices Face the Most Risk?

The podiatry practices facing the most risk are those with high routine foot care volume, frequent same-day E/M visits billed with modifier 25, heavy DME ordering, recent Medicare enrollment, or past overpayment findings. These are the billing patterns federal auditors have already flagged in podiatry, and the patterns new data tools are designed to spot.

Routine foot care is the clearest exposure. In its audit A-09-22-03011, Podiatrists’ Claims for Routine Foot Care Services Did Not Comply With Medicare Requirements, the OIG found that 49 of 100 sampled claims for routine foot care tied to a systemic condition did not meet Medicare requirements, an estimated $4.4 million in improper payments for 2019 and 2020. The main problems were insufficient documentation and incorrect coding, such as nail and lesion counts that did not match the note.

Modifier 25 is the larger dollar figure. A companion OIG audit estimated $39.6 million in improper payments for E/M services billed by podiatrists with modifier 25. That same billing pattern is already under payment pressure, as our modifier 25 payment cut guide explains.

DME ordering adds a third layer. CMS has been barring suppliers for fraudulent billing, as covered in our report on the CMS DMEPOS fraud crackdown, and practices that order orthotics and wound supplies through those channels sit closer to that scrutiny than they may realize.

One question we hear constantly from practice managers is whether a small practice is too small to notice. Data analytics do not care about size; they care about patterns.

Why CMS Wanted Exclusion Power

CMS framed the request around speed and alignment. As the agency processing claims, enrolling providers, and running program integrity contractors, it already holds the data that shows unusual billing. Until October 14, turning that evidence into an exclusion meant handing the case to the OIG. The delegation lets CMS act directly while the OIG keeps its own authority, which some law firms now describe as two agencies holding the same tool.

The financial stakes explain the push. CMS has credited its program integrity efforts with $41.9 billion in savings for fiscal year 2025, and the agency’s leadership has been public about wanting faster action against providers who bill improperly. Payment suspensions, which temporarily withhold some or all Medicare payments while concerns are investigated, are one of the fastest tools available, which is why Brandt set a quadrupling goal for them.

The signal for podiatry is that enforcement is shifting from after-the-fact recovery to earlier intervention. Historically, a practice with documentation problems might face an audit, an overpayment demand, and an appeal over many months. Under a model built around suspensions, monitoring, and a second agency with exclusion power, consequences can arrive sooner and with less warning. Exclusion still requires a legal basis such as a fraud conviction, a kickback, or a pattern of excessive charges or unnecessary services under section 1128(b)(6), but suspensions and audits can start well before any of that is proven.

In our experience matching providers with billing partners, practices that already run internal claim audits barely notice these shifts. Practices that rely on templates and hope tend to feel them first.

What Could a Payment Suspension Cost a Podiatry Practice?

A payment suspension can cost a podiatry practice its entire Medicare cash flow for the length of the review, while staff, rent, and supply costs keep running. Because podiatry panels skew heavily toward Medicare patients, even a short suspension can create a cash crisis long before any overpayment is confirmed.

Consider an illustrative scenario. A two-podiatrist practice collects about $60,000 a month from Medicare, mostly routine foot care, nail debridement, wound care, and E/M visits. If a contractor suspends payments while it reviews documentation, and the review takes 90 days, the practice goes three months without roughly $180,000 in expected revenue. Even if most claims are ultimately paid, the practice may need a line of credit to make payroll, and any claims found unsupported become overpayments on top of the delay. The figures are hypothetical, but the math is why prevention costs far less than recovery. A practice that cannot show a recent internal audit also has a harder time arguing that problems were isolated.

The most common triggers are familiar ones. Nail debridement billed with CPT 11721 on a schedule that does not match documented findings, class findings that do not support the Q modifier billed, and E/M visits on nearly every procedure day all stand out in data. Our coverage of rising podiatry claim denials in 2026 shows the same issues already driving denials.

Providers often come to us after receiving their first additional documentation request, wishing they had reviewed their own claims sooner.

What Should Podiatry Practices Do Now?

Podiatry practices should audit a sample of routine foot care and modifier 25 claims, screen staff against exclusion lists monthly, and make sure every claim tells the same story as the chart. The goal is to find and fix patterns internally before a contractor finds them first.

  1. Audit a claim sample. Pull 20 to 30 recent routine foot care and E/M claims and compare each to the note line by line.
  2. Verify Q modifier support. Confirm the documented class findings match the Q7, Q8, or Q9 modifier billed on each claim.
  3. Check nail and lesion counts. Make sure the units billed match the number documented in the procedure note.
  4. Review modifier 25 use. Confirm each same-day E/M addresses a separately identifiable problem beyond the procedure.
  5. Screen staff and vendors monthly. Check employees and contractors against the OIG exclusion list, since payments tied to excluded individuals are not allowed.
  6. Respond to records requests fast. Assign one owner for additional documentation requests and track every deadline.
  7. Document corrective action. Keep a written record of audit findings, staff training, and fixes made.

For the specific modifier rules auditors check, our Q8 modifier routine foot care guide walks through the class findings each modifier requires. Repeat the audit every quarter and compare results over time so you can show improvement if a contractor ever asks. A practice that can produce a dated audit log, staff training records, and corrected templates is in a much stronger position during any review.

Enforcement is moving faster, and podiatry billing patterns are already on federal radar.

In our experience, practices with a podiatry-focused billing partner catch documentation gaps before auditors do. Get matched with podiatry billing companies free, in as little as 30 minutes.

Common Misreadings of the Delegation

The first misreading is that CMS can now exclude anyone for a billing mistake. It cannot. The delegation created no new grounds for exclusion. CMS still needs a basis listed in section 1128(b), such as certain convictions, kickbacks, license actions, or excessive charges and unnecessary services, plus the evidence to support it. An honest coding error is far more likely to lead to an overpayment demand than an exclusion.

The second misreading is that nothing has changed because the rules are the same. The rules are the same, but the number of agencies able to act on them doubled, and the stated goal for payment suspensions is four times the current level. More reviewers looking at the same data means problems surface faster.

The third misreading confuses the tools. A payment suspension temporarily withholds payments during a review. A revocation ends a provider’s Medicare billing privileges. An exclusion bars an individual or entity from all federal health programs, and no federal program will pay for items or services they furnish, order, or prescribe. Each has different triggers and very different consequences.

The fourth misreading is that only owners need to worry. An excluded employee or contractor can create liability for the practice that employs them, which is why monthly exclusion screening belongs in every podiatry office. The same applies to billing vendors and locum podiatrists who submit claims under your practice.

The most common issue we see providers run into is treating compliance as a once-a-year project instead of a monthly habit.

In-House vs. Outsourced Billing Compliance

Small practices can run their own compliance checks if someone has time each month to pull a sample, review notes, and fix templates. In practice, that work usually loses to scheduling, prior authorizations, and patient calls. When audits slip, the patterns auditors look for keep building quietly in the claims data.

Ask any prospective billing company how it audits routine foot care claims, how it decides when modifier 25 is supported, and how it handles an additional documentation request from start to finish. Ask for sample audit reports from current podiatry clients too. The answers show whether a partner treats compliance as part of the job or as an extra service.

Many billing companies in our network build compliance into the billing workflow itself, scrubbing routine foot care claims for modifier support, flagging modifier 25 overuse, and helping practices respond to records requests. Many also work inside the systems podiatry practices already use, including Modernizing Medicine EMA, Practice Fusion, DrChrono, Kareo, athenahealth, AdvancedMD, and Podiatry Genius.

Podiatry Bill Co is part of the Billing Service Quotes network, which has matched more than 2,000 providers across all 50 states, brings over 15 years of industry experience, and offers billing rates starting as low as 2.95%. Requests are reviewed by a real person, including Tim Daniels, Director of Strategic Accounts at Billing Service Quotes, who helps podiatry practices connect with billing companies that understand routine foot care rules, surgical billing, and audit response. Most practices are matched in as little as 30 minutes at no cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did CMS get exclusion authority?

HHS delegated permissive exclusion authority under section 1128(b) of the Social Security Act to the CMS Administrator in a Federal Register notice published October 14, 2026, Document 2026-21001. The delegation took effect immediately and does not reduce the OIG’s existing exclusion authority.

Can CMS exclude a podiatrist for a coding error?

Not on that basis alone. The delegation created no new grounds for exclusion, so CMS still needs a statutory basis under section 1128(b) and supporting evidence. Coding errors typically lead to denials or overpayment demands, though repeated patterns of unnecessary services can raise more serious concerns.

What is the difference between a payment suspension and an exclusion?

A payment suspension temporarily withholds some or all Medicare payments while CMS or a contractor investigates a concern. An exclusion bars a provider from all federal health programs, so no federal program pays for services they furnish, order, or prescribe. Suspensions can start long before any wrongdoing is proven.

Why are podiatry claims a frequent audit target?

OIG audits found that 49 of 100 sampled podiatry routine foot care claims did not meet Medicare requirements and estimated $39.6 million in improper modifier 25 E/M payments to podiatrists. Documentation gaps, unsupported Q modifiers, and mismatched nail or lesion counts were common findings.

How often should a podiatry practice screen staff for exclusions?

Monthly screening against the OIG exclusion list is a widely used best practice, along with screening at hire. Because federal programs will not pay for services tied to excluded individuals, catching a problem quickly limits the practice’s exposure to repayment and penalties.

Next Steps

Protect your Medicare revenue before enforcement reaches your claims.

Get matched with podiatry billing companies that know routine foot care rules, modifier 25, and audit response. Billing Service Quotes has matched 2,000+ providers in all 50 states, with rates starting as low as 2.95%. Matching is 100% free.

Get Matched In 30 Minutes

Get a FREE Quote

Tell us about your practice and we'll connect you with trusted billing companies.

100% Free to providers — No hidden fees at any stage

Where should we send your quote(s)?

We'll send it directly to your inbox

How many providers does your practice have?

We'll find a billing company that can support your needs

Where is your practice located?

We'll find a billing company that serves providers in your area

loading
Tim Daniels
Online now
Tim Daniels

How can I help?

Send me your number and I'll personally call you in less than 24 hours to discuss any questions you may have about our podiatry billing partners

Mon–Fri, 9:00am–5:30pm Or email instead →
Got it — talk soon.
I'll call you within one business hour. Check your phone for an unknown number.